The Chain Reaction:
December 2, 1942 and After
An Exhibition in the Department of Special Collections,
University of Chicago Library
October 1, 1992 - December 4, 1992
Topical divisions of the exhibition:1. The Chain Reaction 2. The Atomic Scientists of Chicago
This exhibition was organized to commemorate the fiftieth anniversary of the world's first controlled, self-sustaining nuclear chain reaction, an achievement of Enrico Fermi and his colleagues at the Metallurgical Laboratory at the University of Chicago.
Based on the papers of individual scientists and records of scientists' associations, the text of the exhibition begins with an account of the construction and operation of the first nuclear pile beneath the West Stands of Stagg Field on the campus of the University of Chicago. The exhibition examines the concerns of atomic scientists from Chicago and elsewhere over the dangers of nuclear power, and it then traces the scientists' post-World War II campaigns of public education and legislation to assure civilian control of atomic energy.
- For further information on this exhibition and related manuscript and archival collections, please contact:
- Special Collections Research Center
- University of Chicago Library
- 1100 E. 57th Street
- Chicago, Illinois 60637
- SpecialCollections@lib.uchicago.edu
On December 2, 1942, scientists at the University of Chicago produced
the world's first self-sustaining nuclear chain reaction in a nuclear
pile constructed in a squash court beneath the West Stands of Stagg
Field, the University's athletic stadium. This experiment, crucial to
the control of nuclear fission, was one of several research projects
at sites around the country, each concentrating on some task critical
to production of an atomic bomb. All were administered by the
U.S. Army under the code name of Manhattan Engineer District, or
Manhattan Project. After the discovery of nuclear fission in 1938 by German chemists Otto
Hahn and Fritz Strassman, theorizing and experimentation in this
country had proceeded rapidly at Columbia, Princeton, Berkeley,
Chicago, and elsewhere. Enrico Fermi, who had defected from Italy
while accepting the Nobel Prize in physics, arrived at Columbia in
1939 where he theorized that the neutrons emitted in fission might
induce fission reactions. Fermi further concluded that it should be
possible to sustain a chain reaction in uranium which, under the right
conditions, might multiply fast enough to cause a nuclear explosion.
Fermi and Columbia physicist Leo Szilard proposed placing uranium in a
matrix of graphite, forming a cubical lattice of uranium with
potential for inducing a self-sustaining controlled reaction. Amid fears that German scientists might already be well on their way
to constructing an atomic weapon, President Roosevelt in the fall of
1941 approved a full-scale effort to translate these theories into the
construction of the bomb. Arthur Holly Compton, professor of physics
at the University of Chicago and a Nobel laureate, was placed in
charge of the program with work on a reactor to be concentrated in
Chicago under the code name Metallurgical Laboratory. Consequently,
early in 1942 groups of scientists from Princeton and Columbia arrived
at Chicago to combine their efforts. In November 1942 construction began on the reactor in the West
Stands. Layers of graphite blocks containing slugs of uranium metal
and uranium oxide alternated with layers of solid graphite blocks, in
a roughly spherical shape supported by a wood framework. A square
balloon-cloth bag encased the reactor to reduce absorption of
neautrons by nitrogen in the air. Higher grades of uranium became
available as work progressed, and the pile was redesigned in a reduced
size with a flattened top. Construction halted with the fifty-seventh layer on December 1, when
measurements indicated the pile would become sulf-sustaining should
the control rods be withdrawn. On December 2, Fermi and his
colleagues gathered on the balcony of the squash court to test the
reactor, slowly withdrawing the last control rod until the "critical,"
or self-sustaining, level was reached, then watching the reactor
operate for twenty-eight minutes before reinserting the rod and
stopping the reaction. Compton telephoned the news to Harvard
president James B. Conant, member of the Manhattan Project Military
Policy Committee, with the coded message, "The Italian navigator has
just landed in the New World." Chicago was one of the earliest centers where apprehension about the
dangers of nuclear research found expression. By the summer of 1943,
Chicago staff members were voicing their concerns in private
conversation, as well as at several meetings held with project
permission, but with guards present. At one of these gatherings, James
Franck, a German Jewish refugee who had become professor of chamistry
at the University in 1938, spoke movingly from his own experience of
the danger of governmental control over science. Throughout 1944, the scientists expressed their opinions with
increasing frequency and clarity. Compton and the Metallurgical
Project council authorized a committee headed by Zay Jeffries to
appraise the future of nuclear research. The Jeffries Report,
submitted to Compton on November 18, 1944, included a lengthy section
concerning the grave dangers posed by nuclear weapons, the need for
education of the general public, and the critical importance of
international controls. Meanwhile, a group of twenty-two Chicago
scientists headed by Sammuel Allison, recommended to Washington that
the United States forewarn its allies of the bomb. In June of 1945, when the U.S. War Department formed an Interim
Committee to recommend executive and legislative policies for nuclear
energy in the postwar period, the Met Lab scientists organized
committees to transmit their views to Washington. Franck chaired the
Committee on Social and Political Implications which drafted a report
underlining the need for international controls and anticipating the
nuclear arms race. The committee urged that the atomic bomb be
demonstrated to Japanese leaders in an uninhabited place rather than
dropped without warning, arguing that "if the United States were to be
the first to release this new means of indiscriminate destruction upon
mankind, she would sacrifice public support throughout the world,
precipitate the race for armaments, and prejudice the possibility of
reaching an international argreement on the future of such weapons." The bombing of Hiroshima heightened the urgency of earlier decisions,
and the Franck Committee called an open meeting of the Chicago staff
on the evening of August 7, 1945, the day following the bombing.
Those gathered designated Eugene Rabinowitch chair of a group to draft
a statement arguing for civilian administration of atomic research,
international controls to head off an arms race (including the
possibility of world government as a means to this end), and the need
to educate scientists, governmental leaders, and the public about
atomic weapons as well as about potential energy applications. Chicago scientists were particularly concerned about federal
legislation, especially in regard to secrecy and military control in
atomic research. Leo Szilard, who had come to Chicago from Columbia
University in 1942, and who was an active member of the Franck
Committee, outlined in early September a "platform for conversations"
with members of Congress, signalling the key role which Chicago
scientists were to play in congressional lobbying. By September 14, a
Planning Committee was circulating a "Statement of Intent" for the
association that was to organize itself officially a few days later as
the Atomic Scientists of Chicago. The May-Johnson Bill, introduced in Congress in early October, called
for stringent security restrictions, failed to provide for the sharing
of information with foreign countries, and granted a dominant role to
the military, which galvanized scientists throughout the country.
Fledgling organizations at several research sites began issuing press
releases, writing to the War Department, and wiring members of
Congress to point out the bill's shortcomings. John A. Simpson, chair
of the executive committee of the Atomic Scientists of Chicago, joined
William Higinbotham of the Los Alamos group in coordinating the
Washington effort, notifying local organizations of critical turns of
events, and attempting to channel the energies of eager scientists who
appeared in the capital to volunteer. With the tabling of the May-Johnson Bill in December, due in part to
lobbying by scientists' groups, the Atomic Scientists of Chicago turned
their attention to popular education, particularly in the Midwest.
The ASC editorial group prepared a pamphlet, The Atomic Bomb,
which was ready for distribution in mid-Feburary 1946. During the
winter of 1945-1946, the ASC speakers bureau filled an average of one
request per day from schools, churches and synagogues, clubs, and
business associations. Over forty members used these opportunities
to explain the essential facts of atomic energy and impress on the
public the need for international control of arms and civilian control
of research.
Goldsmith and Rabinowitch guided the enterprise, which had an almost
immediate impact far beyond the Chicago area. Goldsmith, a physicist,
had wide contacts outside the scientific community, something that set the
Bulletin of Atomic Scientists apart fron other site
newsletters; and Rabinowitch, a Russian-born biophysicist who had
collaborated with James Franck at Goettingen in the early 1930s, was
talented writer with a deep and longstanding concern about the bomb's
practical and social implications. He had played a key role in
formulating the Franck Coimmittee report and in the organiztion of
the ASC. The first issue of the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists of
Chicago appeared on December 10, 1945. Its six pages featured an
ASC press release on the anniversary of Pearl Harbor pointing out
the futility of nuclear preparedness and urging efforts to achieve
international control. From the beginning, the editors were
interested in distributing the Bulletin not only locally and
at other research sites, but to interested or influential
"nonscientific" groups and individuals. Reflecting its broad appeal, the Bulletin dropped of
Chicago from its name in the seventh issue (March 15, 1946) and
published an increasingly wide range of articles, from the technical
("Can Air or Water Be Exploded?" by physicist H. A. Bethe) to the
general ("The Moral Reponsibilities of Scientists" by British
physiologist A. V. Hill). The editors continued to publish important
primary documents such as the report of the State Department Committee
on Atomic Energy, which was hailed as the first stop toward
international control. Commentary by scientists frequently
accompanied such documents, in this instance by Harold Urey, professor
in the University of Chicago Department of Chemistry and wartime
director of a Manhattan Project laboratory at Columbia University. It was not until 1947 that the Bulletin cover began to
display the Doomsday Clock which, originally intended to mark halting
progress toward arms control, has since become symbolic of the
Bulletin's cause. Designed by Martyl Langsdorf, the wife of
a Manhattan Project physicist, the clock evoked both the imagery of
the Apocalypse, and the contemporary idiom of military attack -- the
countdown to zero hour. The precise location of the minute hand took
on greater significance when the editors decided to move it to reflect
changes in international security. Having begun at eight minutes
before midnight, the clock has been as close as two minutes, where it
stood from 1953 to 1960 following nearly simulataneous detonations of
hydrogen bombs by the United States and the Soviet Union. The clock
has moved forward and back fourteen times, and since 1988 has been
pushed backward from six to seventeen minutes to midnight.1. The Chain Reaction
The University of Chicago is not only the site of the world's first
self-sustaining nuclear reaction, but also one of the earliest and
most influential centers of the atomic scientists' movement.2. The Atomic Scientists of Chicago
While research continued at Chicago, primary attention shifted to
weapon development at Oak Ridge, Los Alamos, and elsewhere, and some
Chicago scientists were transferred to these projects. Samuel
K. Allison, one of the scientists who moved to Los Alamos, was present
at the detonation of the first atomic bomb in the desert at
Alamogordo, New Mexico, on July 16, 1945. Three weeks later, the
first atomic bomb was dropped over Hiroshima, Japan.3. The Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists
Perhaps the most concrete demonstration of the commitment of the
Chicago scientists to educate themselves and others, and the most
enduring symbol of the scientists' movement as a whole, was the
Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists. This publication was
reputedly conceived in the unlikely setting of the Stineway
Drug Store on 57th Street just east of the University of Chicago campus, where Eugene Rabinowitch, Hy Goldsmith, and
social scientist Edward Shils met to drink coffee, discuss means of
weighing issues, and share opinions in the atomic policy debate. On
the basis of a proposal from Rabinowitch and Goldsmith, the Atomic
Scientists of Chicago
executive committee on November 24, 1945, authorized a newsletter
with weekly committee reports, items from other site newsletters, and
responsible statements as well as "terrible stuff" from the public press.
