| Year | Class | Prize Recipient | Collection Title |
| 2008 | 4th-years | Elizabeth Litchfield | A Library of Love: Challenging the Social Order One Couple (or Threesome?) at a Time |
| Elizabeth
Davidson, Honorable Mention |
Religion in Late Antique Egypt | ||
| 2nd-year | Aaron Vanides | Into the Mists of the North: A Comparative Collection of the Medieval Germanic Tradition and its Modern Manifestation | |
| 2007 | 4th-year | Donna Zuckerberg | Homer and His Students |
| 2nd-year | Erin Wonder | Cultured Insolence: Wit in British Literature | |
| 2006 | 4th-year | Quinn Anya Carey | Languages and Linguistics of the Former USSR |
| 2nd-year | Sabahat F. Adil | From Málaga To Miyagi- Collected Wisdoms of the Seeker | |
| 2005 | 4th-year | Benjamin Trofatter | INIM.MEŠ, AMATU, uddar ("Words, Words, Words"): A Collection of the Languages and Literatures of the Ancient Near East |
| 2004 | 4th-years | Ian R. B. Desai | Where Poetry Comes to Live |
| Austin
Bean Honorable Mention |
Alternatives to, Defenses of, Mathematical Orthodoxies | ||
| 2003 | 4th-years | Rukmini Singh | Manga (Japanese Comics), Shoujo Manga ( Girl's Comics) and Boys' Love |
| Christian
Kammerer, Honorable Mention |
Man and Fish | ||
| Margo
Miller, Honorable Mention |
Rock Writing and the Vinyl Closet | ||
| 2002 | 4th-years | Rachel Anne Dion | Ancient Egypt |
| Licsi Aniko Szatmari | The Development of Sufism in Iran and Central Asia | ||
| Jessica
B. Ferguson, Honorable Mention |
Modern Central European Literature in Translation | ||
| 2nd-years
|
Zachary Martin | First Person Masculine American Travel Literature | |
| Ian
R. B. Desai, Honorable Mention |
Enduring Verse: Ancient Legacy/ Modern Inheritance | ||
| 2001 | 4th-years | Patrick Earnest | Suicidal Writers and Their Works |
|
Elisha Fishbane, |
Jewish Mystical Literature | ||
| 2nd-year |
Kristin Paige Schmidt |
Gnosticism and Its Early Christian Context | |
| 2000 |
2nd-years |
Moshe Krakowski | Jewish Studies |
|
Jared Ronai Shurin |
Robert Graves: His Life and Works | ||
|
Aniko Szatmari |
The Marriage of Philo and Sophia: Love and Knowledge in Medieval Islam and the European Renaissance | ||
| 1999 | 4th-year | Katharine Olson | Cymru am byth: The Language, Literature, and History of Wales |
| 1998 | 4th-years | Sherlina Nageer | Literature and Poetry from the Caribbean |
| The New Latin American Narrative | |||
| 2nd-year |
John Allread |
Hoosier Notables: 1880-1930 | |
| 1997 | 4th-year | Abstract Expressionism | |
| 2nd-year |
Nathan H. Mauk |
The Epistemology of Meaning and Communication | |
| 1996 | 4th-years |
Nathanael Crawford |
From "Mankind" to Midwives: The John Newberry Medal |
| A Bookmaker's Books: A Collection of Fine Printed and Handmade Books | |||
| 1995 | 4th-years |
Gregory Vargo |
Contemporary American Poetry |
| Fairytales and Folklore | |||
| 2nd-year |
Taska Moira Harnischfeger |
Imagination and Prophecy: Early to Modern Classics of Fantasy and Science Fiction | |
| 1994 | 4th-year | U.S. Highways | |
| Honorable Mention |
Daska Babcock |
Issues of Women around the World | |
| 1993 | 4th-year | Catholic Literature with a special emphasis on English Converts | |
| 2nd-year |
John Ward |
18th Century French Decorative Arts and the English Country House | |
| 1992 | 4th-year | The History of Paleonanthropology and Archeology | |
| 2nd-year |
Benjamin Wiener |
Media and Mass Culture and the Works of Don DeLillo | |
| 1991 | 4th-year |
David A. Gemunder |
American Antebellum and Civil War History |
| 2nd-year |
Brian Huelsmann |
Experimental Literature and Modern German Literature and its Precursors | |
| 1990 | 4th-year |
Mark M. Levandoski |
Vladimir Nabokov |
| 2nd-year | Nathan Ferguson | Michael Moorcock |